Skip to main content

Blood - Red (US vs. Italy)

I think soccer fans will be talking about this game for years to come. An 9-man USA team outplayed a 10-man Italy team to hold on to a 1-1 draw. (I was right by the way in my last article with the score prediction.) There was much red seen in this match - from McBride's face to Mastroeni's studs-up tackle.

I felt the first red card, given to an Italian, was definitely warranted. There is no question. As a referree, I felt the second red card was also appropriate. I'm sorry if you had to listen to Marcelo Balboa rant on-and-on about how the referree was ruining the match. I cannot believe that a soccer player with the experience of Balboa would have been such an idiot. As I said, I am a referree. We are told to throw a red when a foul is harsh; and/or dangerous; and/or with studs exposed. Mastroeni made a few mistakes. The first mistake: Never foul that roughly when a red card has just been issued. Secondly, if studs are out, do not straighten your leg when going through the tackle. Thirdly, do not be late, or Get the ball! From a fan's perspective, a red card seems rediculous. However, I cannot see the referree arm of FIFA taking action against the referree of today's match for that call.

As far as Pope's second yellow/subsequent red, I felt and said that Arena should have taken out Pope. I realize that would have eliminated some athleticism in our attack, but I think a red card does even more damage. I wish Arena's thinking would have been along this line: "Man, two reds have already been issued. Eddie (Pope) has been close once already to picking up that second yellow. Maybe I should take him out." Unfortunately, that did not happen. I cannot be certain, but having a 10-on-10 match may have resulted in a win for us today.

For the record, Balboa's statement concerning the inconsistency in the referree's calling today from 1st half to the end of the 2nd was absolutely absurd. For a referree, these are the priorities:
  1. Safety (big in FIFA)
  2. Fair Play (also big)
  3. Game control*** and law enforcement (not police...)

Sometimes in controlling a game, cards must be given out early. The principle is: "Better an early yellow than a late red." An early yellow in a tightly called match is much better than having to throw a red in an out-of-control match. I thought the referree had constant control today.

Maybe what I hate the most is the attitude of the American players. It seems like they all echoed an anti-referree sentiment after the match. I think this shows their immaturity as professionals. I thought for sure, especially with veterans like Pope and Mastroeni, that they would not have acted like 20-year olds. (which happens to be my age)

What we need to advance to the Round of 16:

- A win against a tough Ghana side

- An Italian win against an angry Czech side

- Multiple goals for Us in the win against Ghana.

Stay tuned! Thursday, 9:55 a.m. EST. The US/Ghana game and the Czech/Italy game will be aired simultaneously on ESPN and ESPN2, respectively.

Suggested line-up:

GK: Keller

D: Bocanegra, Gooch, Cherundolo

MF: O'Brien (D-Mid), Beasley(LWM), Donovan(LCM), Reyna(RCM), Dempsey (RWM)

F: Eddie Johnson, McBride

Popular posts from this blog

USA v. Ghana: Line-up & Prediction

This is the most interesting game of the tournament as far as what is at stake. The USA need a win by at least 3 goals if the Czech and Italians were to tie. If Italy were to beat the Czech, all the USA would need is a win. Here is my "best-bet" line-up: GK - Keller D - Bocanegra, Gooch (yc), Cherundolo MF - Beasley, Reyna (yc), Dempsey, O'Brien, Donovan F - McBride, E. Johnson Notes: - 3 in the back will force play outside; Dempsey (RWM) and Beasley (LWM) are fast enough to play both ways - Midfield control will be the most crucial factor to a multi-goal win. We will not counter-attack well with the speed of the Ghana side. Also, if we don't control the midfield, Michael Essien will. - I think McBride and Johnson are the best bet up front. McBride receives the ball well. Johnson's size, quickness, and skill will serve us well. - A big question is who will play Def. MF. With no Mastroeni, we resort to either Dempsey or O'Brien in a 3-5-2 formation. SUBS: - Con...
Read more

Favre Talking Points

I was a closet Green Bay fan in high school, mainly because of some big-time Packer fans in my church. Granted, it was easy to pull for them, since they weren't rivals with America's Team -- that's right! What intrigues me the most is that three teams took different approaches to Brett Favre, and I believe they would've have been mistaken to respond differently. Packers were criticized (as was Favre) for not letting Favre come back. I'm sure there are still some detractors that would say Favre would've won more games than Rodgers (6). What's interesting is that Aaron Rodgers QB stats (other than wins) were better than Favre's. The point is that, the Packers weren't going to win the NFC last season, with or without #4. They could be a Super Bowl team in 2-3 years. The Packers made a great move by parting with Favre. It couldn't have happened better for them. Jets are a bit more troublesome to parse apart. The only thing that makes them look foolis...
Read more

Don't be 'Joe Fan'

The response from Wednesday's USA last minute thriller versus Algeria felt like the crest of a crescendo that had been swelling since 2000 or so, or maybe even 1996 at the outset of MLS. My favorite US Soccer fan type is 'Joe Fan' who only watches soccer for 1 month out of every four years. He knows general soccer lingo. He even knows the favorites to win the tournament. None of these, though, is his calling card. You'll know Joe Fan by this very one thing -- as the World Cup is discussed among him, he'll whip out his anti-USA soccer spiel that he's been working on all week, or worse -- the one he heard from Michael Wilbon on PTI the previous afternoon. Most Joe Fan-types have these things in common: They think soccer is boring because there isn't much scoring. Soccer isn't even as big as hockey in the US, so it must not matter much. He thinks that since the USA isn't a top 10 favorite to win the World Cup, they must not be any good. He sees the USA ...
Read more